MacSinclair’s Literary Dwelling

The Top Ten Best Albums from the 1960s. The Beatles, The Kinks, The Rolling Stones, et al.

Posted on | January 10, 2009 |

Just For Fun

Just for fun, and since I like lists, I thought I would share what I think are the best albums from the 1960s. It is both an objective and a subjective list. The repetition of certain groups shows my leanings, I suppose. In my head, I have the next ten, and the next after that. So the next ten, for anyone protesting their exclusion, is where you would find The Beach Boys Pet Sounds, Dylan’s Basement Tapes, The Rolling Stone’s Beggars Banquet, etc.

The MacSinclair Top Ten in the Canon of 1960s Albums.

1. If you only owned two or three Beatles albums, you must own this one. Ray Davies claimed that John and Paul must have chained the conservative George Martin to a post to get away with what they did here in 1966. The range of styles is amazing. The experimentation is unique because it is so accesible. And I dont think there is any album that has such a combination of ornamental baroque pieces juxtaposed to sonic acid / psychedelic blasts.

1. If you only owned two or three Beatles albums, you must own this one. Ray Davies claimed that John and Paul must have chained the conservative George Martin to a post to get away with what they did here in 1966. The range of styles is amazing. The experimentation is unique because it is so accesible. And I don't think there is any album that has such a combination of ornamental baroque pieces juxtaposed to sonic acid / psychedelic blasts.

2. Yes, two Beatles in a row. But they simply are the best, and not overrted. I think you could swap number one and two positions here if you want. This is a put on the smoking jacket and drink a dry scotch Beatles album. Although they were influenced by Dylan here, they make folk very much their own. Its too bad they had to end with one of the worst throw-away songs ever, Run For Your Life. Lennon said it was one of the worst songs he ever wrote.

2. Yes, two Beatles in a row. But they simply are the best, and not overrted. I think you could swap number one and two positions here if you want. This is a put on the smoking jacket and drink a dry scotch Beatles album. Although they were influenced by Dylan here, they make folk very much their own. It's too bad they had to end with one of the worst throw-away songs ever, "Run For Your Life." Lennon said it was one of the worst songs he ever wrote.

3. The Village Greene Preservation Society. The Kinks. When all the big groups went big and loud in 1968, the Kinks went quiet and pastoral. Kinks maniacs argue endlessly over which album is their best. To me, this is their masterpiece. For one, its as bold as you can get. What group in 1968 argued to preserve china cups and virginity? Secondly, I challenge you to find a greater collection of baroque pop music anywhere. All twee and baroque rock so big in the past ten years has roots in this Dylan Thomas vision of British village life.

3. The Village Greene Preservation Society. The Kinks. When all the big groups went big and loud in 1968, the Kinks went quiet and pastoral. Kinks maniacs argue endlessly over which album is their best. To me, this is their masterpiece. For one, it's as bold as you can get. What group in 1968 argued to preserve china cups and virginity? Secondly, I challenge you to find a greater collection of baroque pop music anywhere. All twee and baroque rock so big in the past ten years has roots in this Dylan Thomas vision of British village life.

4. Sell Out. The Who. Pretending to be one hour of music on Radio London, I think this is the best concept album around. But get the expanded reissue. It includes a shit-load of bonus material and extra mock advertisements, which seems to come close to finishing the Whos original and incomplete vision. This album roams from psychedelia to rock to drop dead gorgeous ballads to hilarious satire. This is a creative range hard to find anywhere. If you like 60s music and you dont have this one, dont walk, run to the computer and order it. Now! Im serious.

4. Sell Out. The Who. Pretending to be one hour of music on Radio London, I think this is the best concept album around. But get the expanded reissue. It includes a shit-load of bonus material and extra mock advertisements, which seems to come close to finishing the Who's original and incomplete vision. This album roams from psychedelia to rock to drop dead gorgeous ballads to hilarious satire. This is a creative range hard to find anywhere. If you like 60s music and you don't have this one, don't walk, run to the computer and order it. Now! I'm serious.

5. Bob Dylan. Bringing it all Back Home. OK, Im up against a wall here. I tend to lump this one along with Highway 61 Revisited and Blonde on Blonde as the trinity of Dylan best. So, Im cheating and presenting all three as #5. Besides, if you dont have all three, and you love 60s music, and you love Dylan, then you have a big black hole in your collection, and any other Dylan album, or Byrds album or Neil Young album will get sucked into that black hole and die, because these three are the powerful white dwarf threatening to extinguish everything they influence in its path. Enough of the horrible metaphors. Just own them. I never tire of side one to Bringing it all Back. Never.

5. Bob Dylan. Bringing it all Back Home. OK, I'm up against a wall here. I tend to lump this one along with Highway 61 Revisited and Blonde on Blonde as the trinity of Dylan best. So, I'm cheating and presenting all three as #5. Besides, if you don't have all three, and you love 60s music, and you love Dylan, then you have a big black hole in your collection, and any other Dylan album, or Byrds album or Neil Young album will get sucked into that black hole and die, because these three are the powerful white dwarf threatening to extinguish everything they influence in its path. Enough of the horrible metaphors. Just own them. I never tire of side one to Bringing it all Back. Never.

6. Face to Face. The Kinks. Most people think that the big breakthroughs in pop music happened in 1967 with Sergent Peppers. But the big breakthroughs were really in 1966, with Revolver, Aftermath, Pet Sounds, Blonde on Blonde and this one. I think critics have established that this is the first concept album. The Kinks create a walk through daily life of daily people in England. Each song is a snapshot of ordinary experience. When you go from the Kinks first three albums to this one, the jump in creativity is startling. Amazing too is the bits and pieces of influence they use, like music hall, vaudville, ballads, folk all with a combination of satire and heartache. By the way, Davies wrote the girl runs away from home song here one year before the Beatles Shes Leaving Home.

6. Face to Face. The Kinks. Most people think that the big breakthroughs in pop music happened in 1967 with Sergent Pepper's. But the big breakthroughs were really in 1966, with Revolver, Aftermath, Pet Sounds, Blonde on Blonde and this one. I think critics have established that this is the first concept album. The Kinks create a walk through daily life of daily people in England. Each song is a snapshot of ordinary experience. When you go from the Kinks first three albums to this one, the jump in creativity is startling. Amazing too is the bits and pieces of influence they use, like music hall, vaudville, ballads, folk all with a combination of satire and heartache. By the way, Davies wrote the "girl runs away from home" song here one year before the Beatles "She's Leaving Home."

dulcimer, vibes, harpsichord, clavicord. A song like I Am Waiting comes as a wonderful surprise. The album, Flowers, is a different story. Like The Beatles Yesterday and Today, it is a collection of music left off of the butchered American version of their albums in 1966-67. Yet, this one, always underrated, works. Rolling Stone Record review finally gave it five stars in the most recent volume, and called it one of the greatest collection of 1960s music ever. Like the Kinks Face to Face (a HUGE influence on that other 1967 great, Between the Buttons), the album charts the life of a so-called gentleman in what most kids nowadays recognize as the Austin Powers swinging world of London, but with that minor-chord and shadowy edge that the Stones bring to pop. Flowers also sports the most underrated song by the Stones, Backstreet Girl, which originally appeared on the UK version of Between the Buttons. Mick Jagger often claimed it was the best thing they recorded in 1967.

7. Rolling Stones. Flowers and Aftermath. OK, I'm lumping two albums together again. But this is a special case. The Rolling Stones 1960s catalog is, like their music, sort of all over the place. Aftermath was their 1966 breakthrough, their first album of music penned completely by Jaggers / Richards. They fuse the pop craftsmenship of the Beatles with the edgier R & B they had covered previously to create a new and unique sounding pop. Whether they were being balladic, satirical or bluesy, they maintained an ominous, threatening tone. Get the UK version of Aftermath, and, if you can find it, the reissue that includes a bunch of outtakes and unreleased music. Although they did steal the sitar from the Beatles, the Stones incorporate a lot of unique instruments that they make their own: dulcimer, vibes, harpsichord, clavicord. A song like "I Am Waiting" comes as a wonderful surprise. The album, Flowers, is a different story. Like The Beatles Yesterday and Today, it is a collection of music left off of the butchered American version of their albums in 1966-67. Yet, this one, always underrated, works. Rolling Stone Record review finally gave it five stars in the most recent volume, and called it one of the greatest collection of 1960s music ever. Like the Kinks Face to Face (a HUGE influence on that other 1967 great, Between the Buttons), the album charts the life of a so-called gentleman in what most kids nowadays recognize as the Austin Powers swinging world of London, but with that minor-chord and shadowy edge that the Stones bring to pop. Flowers also sports the most underrated song by the Stones, "Backstreet Girl," which originally appeared on the UK version of Between the Buttons. Mick Jagger often claimed it was the best thing they recorded in 1967.

8. Forever Changes. Love. I cant imagine someone who loves 1960s music, particularly of the psychedelic blend, not owning this one. Forget The Doors, I think this is by far the best California psychedlic album you can get. It plays like an awesome soundtrack to everything weird, ominous, magical and precious about this short 1966-68 period in music. Where the use of strings, orchestration, reverb and whatnot frequently comes across as bloated and egregious, Love makes ornamentation work perfectly. I think the first three songs makes for one of the best openings to an album.

8. Forever Changes. Love. I can't imagine someone who loves 1960s music, particularly of the psychedelic blend, not owning this one. Forget The Doors, I think this is by far the best California psychedlic album you can get. It plays like an awesome soundtrack to everything weird, ominous, magical and precious about this short 1966-68 period in music. Where the use of strings, orchestration, reverb and whatnot frequently comes across as bloated and egregious, Love makes ornamentation work perfectly. I think the first three songs makes for one of the best openings to an album.

9. Zombie Heaven. The Zombies. OK, Im cheating here a bit by including a compilation. But this four CD collect EVERYthing this incredible group ever recorded. And there is not one dud in the bunch, making it the best boxset I have ever heard. Although they are one of those quintessential British Invasion groups, the Zombies created a sound entirely their own. Outside of Tell Her No and Time of the Season, they were a commercial flop. My theory as to why they commercially failed is that they were too good. Always working within the 2 -3 minute structure, they created complicated and carefully crafted songs. When you listen to each song, you get the feeling that they did not want to treat any of them as filler or throw-aways. If you dont want to dish out the $$ for the boxset, you must at least get Odyssey and Oracle. It is their stab at making a Sergent Peppers, but, unlike so many other groups, theirs is unique, baroque and every bit an equal to The Beatles--and they had a lot less resources and studio time. Recently, the bastions that canonize these sorts of things have been putting this album on the top album of all time lists.

9. Zombie Heaven. The Zombies. OK, I'm cheating here a bit by including a compilation. But this four CD collect EVERYthing this incredible group ever recorded. And there is not one dud in the bunch, making it the best boxset I have ever heard. Although they are one of those quintessential British Invasion groups, the Zombies created a sound entirely their own. Outside of "Tell Her No" and "Time of the Season," they were a commercial flop. My theory as to why they commercially failed is that they were too good. Always working within the 2 -3 minute structure, they created complicated and carefully crafted songs. When you listen to each song, you get the feeling that they did not want to treat any of them as filler or throw-aways. If you don't want to dish out the $$ for the boxset, you must at least get Odyssey and Oracle. It is their stab at making a Sergent Peppers, but, unlike so many other groups, theirs is unique, baroque and every bit an equal to The Beatles--and they had a lot less resources and studio time. Recently, the bastions that canonize these sorts of things have been putting this album on the top album of all time lists.

10. Something Else. The Kinks. I know. Three on a top ten by the Kinks. I imagine it breaks some top ten rule. As I said, Kink fanatics always argue over which is the best. The Kinks followed up Face to Face with an album just as good, if not better, considering the quality of the recording. Its the same concept of small-life vignettes, but the R&B influence disappears, making it unlike any rock album. Whereas other groups danced in the summer of love in 1967, The Kinks created a sort of bitter-sweet soundtrack of the winter of discontent. The album ends with Waterloo Sunset, a song in the top five of most beautiful ballads ever. Ever.

10. Something Else. The Kinks. I know. Three on a top ten by the Kinks. I imagine it breaks some top ten rule. As I said, Kink fanatics always argue over which is the best. The Kinks followed up Face to Face with an album just as good, if not better, considering the quality of the recording. It's the same concept of small-life vignettes, but the R&B influence disappears, making it unlike any rock album. Whereas other groups danced in the summer of love in 1967, The Kinks created a sort of bitter-sweet soundtrack of the winter of discontent. The album ends with "Waterloo Sunset," a song in the top five of most beautiful ballads ever. Ever.

11. Sergent Peppers Lonely Hearts Club Band. The Beatles. Yes, Im cheating by adding a #11. Consider this a sort of bookend, framing #1 and #2. You hear a lot of musicologists wondering if the album has been overrated. I respond by saying, read Lee Emericks chapter on the making of this album in Here, There and Everywhere. No one before or after has gone to the innovative extents that The Beatles and company went to create an album. In my book, A Day in the Life along makes owning this album essential.

11. Sergent Peppers Lonely Hearts Club Band. The Beatles. Yes, I'm cheating by adding a #11. Consider this a sort of bookend, framing #1 and #2. You hear a lot of musicologists wondering if the album has been overrated. I respond by saying, read Lee Emerick's chapter on the making of this album in Here, There and Everywhere. No one before or after has gone to the innovative extents that The Beatles and company went to create an album. In my book, "A Day in the Life" along makes owning this album essential.

Share and Enjoy:
  • Digg
  • Sphinn
  • del.icio.us
  • Facebook
  • Mixx
  • Google
  • Blogosphere News
  • Reddit
  • StumbleUpon
  • Technorati
Did you like this? If so, please bookmark it,
tell a friend
about it, and subscribe to the blog RSS feed.

Comments

3 Responses to “The Top Ten Best Albums from the 1960s. The Beatles, The Kinks, The Rolling Stones, et al.”

  1. arbiter
    January 11th, 2009 @ 3:11 am

    Mac

    Dear Lord, how could you possibly have left out Captain Beefheart (And His Magic Band), The Electric Prunes, or Booker T. And The M.G.s?

    Seriously, though, I would submit a few additions to your Top 10, including Stan Getz and Joao Gilberto “Getz/Gilberto” (you know, “The Girl from Ipanema, Desafinado, etc.); Simon & Garfunkle (I know, I know) “Parsley, Sage, Rosmary and Thyme; The Band, “Music From Big Pink”; and Big Brother and the Holding Company (and the unbelievable Janis Joplin), “Cheap Thrills” with the cover art by Robert Crumb.

    I was in college in the first part of the 60s and the albums I listened to most aren’t even in the “1001 Albums You Must Hear Before You Die” (do I have enough time left?) But there was some good but obscure folk, some very funny comedy, and some very awful folk and rock as well.

    Will we be reading about your Top 10 for the 1970s?

  2. macsinclair
    January 11th, 2009 @ 3:52 am

    Stan Getz’s album, and the Band Music from Big would be on the next ten. I’m not sure where I’d put Simon and Garf. I’ve always felt that Big Brother and Janis had some great SONGS, but not great albums. At least, the acid rock thing never sat well with me. As I said, the list was both objective and SUBjective. At least four of the ones I chose were on Rolling Stones review top ten. I don’t know Marvin Gaye’s big album enough to really rank it. The problem with lists like this is that there are probably about 50 albums I think are GREAT that I could just put in a list without necessarily placing them in an order. By the way, I kind of like the Electric Prunes first album. did you know their drummer supposedly wrote THE definitive book on drumming? Capt Beef’s “Safe as Milk” is a classic, but I don’t stomach it too well.

  3. Nadine
    February 4th, 2009 @ 5:50 am

    Hi,
    not bad…

    Thanks
    Nadine

Leave a Reply





  • Categories

  • Local Weather

    • Thursday, Mar 18
      Fair
      Currently: 45˚ F
      Feels Like: 42˚ F
      Hi: N/A˚, Lo: 37˚
      Fair

      Tonight: 37˚
      Sunset: 7:01 PM
      Moon Phase: Waxing Crescent
      Partly Cloudy

      Friday, Mar 19
      Hi: 65˚, Lo: 42˚
      Sunny

      weather feed courtesy of weather.com - thanks!

  • Great Music